Boys II Mensa

Plot
It's nearing Halloween and Cory "tests out" a fake, red nose in Mr. Feeny's class, taking the term class clown literally. Mr. Feeny demands he keeps it on the rest of the morning and he returns graded book reports. Cody protests his poor grade and asks why Mr. Feeny picks on him over someone like Minkus. Mr. Feeny all but scoffs at the idea of Minkus doing anything meriting getting "picked on". Cody ends up with detention.

Shawn meets up with Cody after detention (Shawn got his own detention slip from his art teacher) and they find an answer sheet for an upcoming IQ test in the trash. Cody decides to memorize the answers, score high, and finally get Mr. Feeny to treat him as good as Minkus. He scores highest in the school, making Feeny suspicious (though he doesn't voice his suspicions; rather he lavishes over exaggerated praise on Cody ). He sends Cody home with a letter for his parents and after a whole lot of nerves, Shawn opens the letter and learns that their teacher just wants to talk to Cody 's parents. Though Cody is hesitant, Shawn convinces him to keep up the act.

His attempt to look "cultured" involves playing classical music in his room, timed for when his parents walk in. Though they are not fooled at all, they refrain from accusing him in hopes he'll admit what he did. They're interrupted by Morgan in a grisly zombie costume. Eric took her shopping and picked her out the last zombie costume. Though Amy doesn't really care for it, Alan, Eric, and Morgan think it's pretty cool. The next day, Cody confides in Shawn that he doesn't like lying to his parents and feels like the whole 'genius' thing has gotten out of hand. But Shawn and Cody convince themselves it's not technically their fault. Mr Feeny takes Cody out of class to give him one last chance to confess before revealing that Cody is being transferred to a school for prodigies, with no sports. Cody blusters and tries to get out of it but Feeny ominously says that Cody deserves everything he's going to get.

After school, Cody calls Shawn over to yell at him and shoot him with a Nerf gun. He blames Shawn for egging him on to keep up the genius charade. A woman from the gifted school, Ms. Bertram, is coming to give him a test and Shawn thinks Cody should just fail it so he doesn't get accepted. He does so but the snooty Ms Bertram thinks Cody failed the test on purpose so he wouldn't be taken away from his friends. Frustrated with how the whole thing has snowballed, Cody finally confesses to his parents that he cheated on the first test and they confirm that they knew. Ms Bertram is not pleased and leaves, though not before Cody 's parents declare they're proud of their normal kids. Cody 's parents ground him for two weeks but allow him to go trick-or-treating and tell him he doesn't have to be something he's not. The next day, Cody gives up his nose (and the title of class clown) to Mr. Feeny. He finally knows why Mr. Feeny is harder on Cody than other kids who score the same as on tests.

On Halloween, in the post-credits, Mr. Feeny drops by the Matthews' house for some candy since the trick-or-treaters don't like the rulers he's giving out. Three trick-or-treaters show up and one of them, recognizing Mr. Feeny, says that Cody called him the best teacher in the whole school. Feeny, convinced it's Cody, takes off the boy's mask to reveal another kid. Feeny apologizes and gives him the rest of his rulers before leaving. After he's gone, the other two trick-or-treaters take off their masks to reveal Cody and Shawn. "And they say I'm not a genius," brags Cody with a grin.

Starring

 * Thomas Brodie as Cody Matthews
 * Will Friedle as Eric Matthews
 * Rider Strong as Shawn Hunter
 * William Daniels as George Feeny
 * Betsy Randle as Amy Matthews
 * Lee Norris as Stuart Minkus
 * Lily Nicksay as Morgan Matthews
 * William Russ as Alan Matthews

Guest Starring

 * Jane Carr as Ms. Bertram

Featuring

 * Marty York as Costumed Kid #1
 * Sam Horrigan as Costumed Kid #2
 * Dusty Gould as Costumed Kid #3

Quotes
Cody: How come you always pick on me, Mr. Feeny? How come you never pick on Minkus? Feeny: Have you taken a blow to the head, Mr. Matthews? Stuart Minkus gets nothing but A's. If there was a letter before A, he would get that.

Shawn: Who cares if Feeny doesn't think you're brilliant. As long as the test says so. Cody: But I'm not. And my parents know I'm not. Shawn: Then you'll have to make them think you are. Cody: How do I do that? Shawn: Get with the program, Cody. It's Halloween. And this year, you're going as a genius.

Eric: Is my little sister hideous or what? Amy: Eric... Alan: Very gruesome! Blackout teeth? (Morgan shows him her teeth) That's my little girl!

Shawn: Besides, you didn't tell them you were a genius. Feeny did. Cody: And I didn't tell Feeny I'm a genius... Shawn: The test did! And you didn't ask to take the test... Cody: They gave it to me! Shawn: And you wouldn't have even seen the answers... Cody: If they didn't give us- Shawn: -Detention! Cody: We're innocent victims.

Ms. Bertram: So, Mrs. Matthews, you're a housewife? Alan: Uh, Amy's a homemaker. She wrangles three kids, runs this house, and still manages to sell real estate quite successfully. Ms. Bertram: And I understand you work at a grocery store. Amy: Alan is the manager of the largest supermarket in this whole area. Ms. Bertram: Ahh... Tradesmen are so important and yet so little respected.

Ms. Bertram: If yours are the genes that have produced our darling Cody, then perhaps you've done it again with young Morgan here. (Facing Morgan) Shall we try a word association problem? Morgan: Okay Ms. Bertram: "Maple" is to "Elm" as "Daisy" is to...? Morgan: Booger? Ms. Bertram: ...You may go.